How to pour
a rye whiskey in
Let the bottle and glass reach 18 to 20 degrees. Rye is dry and spicy, and that spiciness disappears when the glass is too cold.
Pour 4 cl into the tulip-shaped tasting glass and hold it by the stem so your hand does not warm the whiskey.
Smell it first from a distance and then move closer. Rye gives off a dry, peppery aroma, while bourbon smells mainly sweet and vanilla-like.
Take small sips and pay attention to the finish: that peppery note at the back is exactly what rye brings to a manhattan to counter the sweet vermouth. If desired, add two drops of cold water.
What did you think of this guide?
One click on a star is enough. If you would like to add something, we will read it first before it appears here.
Save this page
Send this page to your own email, so you have the instructions at hand when you are ready to pour. You will also receive a €5 discount code when you spend €50 or more, for the glasses that go with it.
The story
Rye and bourbon come from the same American tradition and the same type of barrel, but they start with a different grain. In bourbon, corn is the main grain, bringing sweetness, vanilla and a rounded body. In rye, rye is the main grain, bringing dryness, pepper and spice. American regulations set a minimum proportion of rye in the mash bill for rye whiskey and require maturation in new charred oak barrels. That new barrel gives a lot of colour and wood in a short time, which is exactly why even a young rye already comes across boldly in the glass.
The right glass
Rye is best tasted neat from a tulip-shaped glass: the bowl captures the dry, spicy aroma and the narrow rim directs it to your nose. The tumbler is shown here too, because rye is just as often served in an Old Fashioned, and there you want room for a large ice cube. We do not sell a glass with the word rye on it; these are the two shapes that do the job. More tumblers can be found among the Old Fashioned glasses.
Schott Zwiesel Bar Special Whisky Tasting Glass 21.8 cl (4 pieces)
Schott Zwiesel Straight Whisky Glass 36.4 cl (6 pieces)
Both sets together € 71,65.
The right tools
For a rye whiskey, alongside the glass, use a jigger to measure 4 cl and a mixing glass when it goes into a Manhattan or an Old Fashioned. These are the bar tools we use ourselves; you can find everything in our bar tools & cocktail sets.
Glass set (our choice 01) + 2 bar tools together € 59,85.
What does this go with?
Rye is part of the American whiskey family. Put it next to bourbon to taste the difference between rye and corn, and next to Jameson to hear what barley does. On every drink page, you can read the percentage, what it tastes like, which cocktails it suits and which glass you need.
Variations & twists
Rye is the original base of the Manhattan, the Sazerac, and the Old Fashioned. In all three, the pepperiness counters the sweetness: the sweet vermouth in the Manhattan and the sugar in the Old Fashioned. If you replace rye with bourbon, the whole drink becomes softer and sweeter, and exactly the friction that gives these classics their bite disappears. Want to read more? Explore all drinks and brands.
Serving tip
Pour 4 cl at 18 to 20 degrees into a tulip-shaped glass and place a glass of cold water next to it. If it goes into an old fashioned, use one large ice cube instead of loose cubes; it melts more slowly and dilutes the drink less. Two drops of water in a neat glass bring out the spices without suppressing the pepper.
Good to know
Rye versus corn
This is the whole difference from bourbon. Corn is bourbon's main grain and brings sweetness, vanilla, and a rounded body. Rye is rye whiskey's main grain and brings dryness, pepper, and spiciness. The same barrel, the same region, a different grain, and therefore a completely different flavor in the glass.
What American regulations require
For rye whiskey, American regulations require a minimum proportion of rye in the mash bill and require aging in new charred oak barrels. The precise proportion of rye in a bottle is not always stated on the label; some distilleries do list their mash bill.
Canadian rye is something entirely different
In Canada, rye has long been used as the common name for Canadian whisky, even when it contains little or no rye. The rules there are much looser than the American ones. So if rye appears on a Canadian bottle, it does not mean the same thing as it does on an American bottle.
Why rye is in the classics
The Manhattan, the Sazerac and the Old Fashioned are built on rye. In all three, something sweet provides contrast: red vermouth, sugar, a dose of bitters. The peppery side of rye pushes back against that and keeps the cocktail dry. With bourbon, the same recipe becomes softer and rounder.
The new charred barrel
American whiskey is aged in new oak barrels whose insides have been charred. Such a barrel imparts color, vanilla and wood notes much faster than a barrel that has been used before. That is why a young American whiskey often already tastes fuller than an equally young whisky from a reused barrel.
What percentage is it
Most bottles start at 40 percent. Cask-strength editions are higher and also drier and more robust. The exact figure is always shown on the bottle's own label.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between rye whiskey and bourbon?
The main grain. Bourbon relies on corn, which makes it sweet, full and rounded. Rye relies on rye, making it dry, peppery and spicy. Both are aged in new charred oak barrels, so the barrel is not the difference - the grain is.
Is Canadian rye the same as American rye whiskey?
No. In Canada, rye has long been a common name for Canadian whisky, even when it contains little or no rye, and the rules there are much more relaxed. American rye must have a minimum proportion of rye in the mash bill and must be aged in new charred oak barrels.
Which cocktails contain rye whiskey?
Rye is the original base of the Manhattan, the Sazerac and the Old Fashioned. In all three, the pepperiness of the rye offsets the sweet element, whether red vermouth or sugar. Replace it with bourbon and the whole thing becomes softer.
Which glass do you use for rye whiskey?
Served neat, pour it into a tulip-shaped tasting glass of roughly 20 cl, on a stem, so your hand does not warm it. If it goes into an old fashioned, it belongs in a tumbler with room for a large ice cube.
Also delicious
Everything for your bar,
to one address
Glasses in hospitality quality, supplied per set. Order today, delivered quickly.
Shop the glasses →