The Brandy Crusta recipe
with a sugar rim and lemon peel collar
Use a vegetable peeler to cut a long, wide strip of zest from a lemon, in one piece all the way around the fruit.
Run an orange or lemon wedge around the outside rim of the glass and dip the rim in fine granulated sugar to create a sugar rim.
Roll up the lemon zest and place it against the inside of the glass as a collar, just below the rim.
Fill a mixing glass with ice and add the brandy, maraschino, curaçao, lemon juice, sugar syrup and bitters.
Stir for 20 seconds until the drink is thoroughly chilled, then carefully strain it into the glass, inside the lemon peel collar.
What did you think of this recipe?
One click on a star is enough. If you would like to add something, we will review it first before it appears here.
Save this recipe
Send the recipe for the Brandy Crusta to your own email, so you have it at hand when you are about to make it. You will also receive a €5 discount code on purchases of €50 or more for the glasses that go with it.
The story
The Brandy Crusta is attributed to Joseph Santini, an Italian-born bartender in New Orleans who is said to have created it around the 1850s. Exactly where is uncertain: his own establishment, the Jewel of the South, and the bar of the St. Louis Hotel are all mentioned. What is certain is that Jerry Thomas included the recipe in his 1862 Bar-Tender's Guide, alongside crusta variations with whisky and gin. The name refers to the sugar crust on the rim. More important was the lemon juice. At the time, a cocktail consisted of spirits, sugar, water and bitters, and Santini added citrus. In doing so, he laid the foundation for later classics such as the Sidecar. The IBA classifies the Brandy Crusta among the Unforgettables.
The right glass
The IBA calls for a narrow cocktail glass, and there is a reason for that: the lemon peel should line the inner rim like a collar, and it will not stay in place in a wide coupe. A 14 to 15.5 cl Nick & Nora glass has the right shape, with a tall, narrow bowl and a stem. With dilution from melted ice, the drink is about 10.5 cl, so it fits perfectly, with room for the peel. You can find them in our Nick & Nora glasses.
RCR Melodia Port Glass Nick & Nora 14 cl (set of 6)
Bormioli Rocco Novecento Cocktail Glass 15.5 cl Nick & Nora (set of 4)
Both sets together € 59,90.
The right tools
For a Brandy Crusta, besides the glass, you need a mixing glass, a bar spoon for stirring, a jigger for precise measuring, a Julep strainer and a bitters bottle. These are the bar tools we use ourselves; you can find them all in our bar tools & cocktail sets.
Glass set (our choice 01) + 5 bar tools together € 131,70.
What do you need to make a Brandy Crusta?
For a Brandy Crusta, you need cognac and liqueur. Popular bottles include Curaçao Triple Sec, Angostura and Hennessy. On each drink page, you can read the alcohol percentage, what it tastes like, which cocktails it pairs with and which glass you need.
Variations & twists
The IBA stirs the Brandy Crusta in a mixing glass. Many bars shake it, which produces a colder, slightly airier drink; both methods are common. Jerry Thomas also described crusta cocktails with whisky and gin, made using the same proportions. If you prefer to keep things simpler, leave out the maraschino, bitters and lemon twist, and you end up with the Sidecar. A lighter cousin with rum added is the Between the Sheets. For another New Orleans classic without citrus, see the Vieux Carré.
Serving tip
First make the sugar rim and lemon twist, then place the garnished glass in the freezer for ten minutes; the sugar will adhere better and the peel will stay in place. Use fine granulated sugar. Powdered sugar dissolves in the lemon juice and becomes sticky.
Good to know
Making a Brandy Crusta: the lemon collar
The lemon-peel collar is what makes a Brandy Crusta distinctive, and with a good vegetable peeler, anyone can make one. Choose a large, firm lemon with a thick peel. Start at the top and peel in a spiral around and downward, in one piece about 2 centimeters wide. Cut away the white pith if it is thick, as it is bitter. Roll up the peel, slide it into the glass, and let it unfold against the sides. It should sit just below the sugar rim, so with each sip you taste the sugar first, followed by the citrus oils.
The sugar rim without clumps
Run an orange or lemon wedge only along the outside of the rim, not over the inside, otherwise the sugar will run into the drink. Sprinkle fine granulated sugar onto a flat saucer and turn the glass upside down through a thin layer; there is no need to press. Let the rim dry for a few minutes before pouring. The IBA specifies powdered white sugar: regular granulated sugar briefly ground finer in a mortar works best. A glass rimmer is faster and neater; see our glass rimmers.
Which brandy for a Brandy Crusta
Cognac VS or VSOP is the most common choice: fruity, not too heavy, and able to stand up to the citrus. A VSOP adds more depth and dried-fruit notes. Armagnac makes the drink more powerful and slightly more rustic, and pairs well with the bitters. Spanish brandy is sweeter and rounder, so you may be able to omit the sugar syrup. What doesn't work is cheap brandy with a sharp, alcoholic nose, because you can't hide it behind such small amounts of liqueur. Taste the brandy neat first: whatever you enjoy drinking that way will also work in the crusta.
Maraschino and curaçao: what they do
Maraschino is a clear liqueur made from marasca cherries from Croatia and Italy, with a dry, slightly nutty flavor that is more reminiscent of almonds than cherries. Luxardo is the best-known bottle. In a Brandy Crusta, it adds a floral undertone; more than 0.75 cl can quickly overpower the drink. Curaçao is an orange liqueur and gives the drink its rounded citrus character. A bar spoon is enough, because the drink gets most of its freshness from the lemon juice. If you don't have curaçao, use a triple sec such as Cointreau; the difference is small.
Difference between Brandy Crusta and Sidecar
The Sidecar is essentially a simplified crusta: cognac, triple sec and lemon juice, shaken and served in a coupe, sometimes with a sugared rim as well. The Brandy Crusta has more layers. The maraschino adds a floral, nutty note, the bitters bring spice and the long lemon peel provides aroma with every sip. The proportions also differ: the crusta uses a lot of brandy and little liqueur and lemon, making it stronger and less sour. If you like the Sidecar and want to try something different, this is a good choice.
How much alcohol is in a Brandy Crusta
The 5.25 cl of 40 percent brandy provides 2.1 cl of pure alcohol. The 32 percent maraschino and curaçao add another approximately 0.4 cl. After twenty seconds of stirring, you have around 10.5 cl in the glass, so you are drinking a cocktail of approximately 24 percent alcohol. That is about two standard drinks. In terms of strength, it is not far below an Old Fashioned, but the lemon juice and sugared rim make it taste much smoother.
Frequently asked questions
What is a Brandy Crusta?
A Brandy Crusta is a classic cocktail from New Orleans made with brandy, maraschino, curaçao, lemon juice, sugar syrup and bitters. It is stirred and served in a narrow glass with a sugared rim and a long curl of lemon peel against the inside. It is considered a predecessor of the Sidecar.
Why is it called a crusta?
The name refers to the sugar crust on the rim of the glass. Crusta comes from the Latin word for crust. Together with the wide collar of lemon peel on the inside, this was a striking presentation in the nineteenth century, and it continues to make the drink recognizable today.
Is the Brandy Crusta the predecessor of the Sidecar?
Yes, that is generally accepted. The Brandy Crusta was one of the first cocktails with lemon juice, and the combination of brandy, orange liqueur and lemon can later be found in the Sidecar. It omitted the maraschino, bitters and lemon collar, making it simpler to prepare.
Which glass do you use for a Brandy Crusta?
A narrow cocktail glass with a stem, such as a 14 to 15.5 cl Nick & Nora glass. The IBA calls for a slim cocktail glass because the lemon peel needs to fit like a collar along the inside. In a wide coupe or martini glass, it will not stay in place.
Everything for your bar,
at one address
Glasses in hospitality quality, supplied per set. Order today, delivered quickly.
Shop the glasses →